Severe Wound Closure


    Wound Assessment

    Timing and Methods

    Pre-closure Steps

    Sutures

    Staples

    Grafts and Flaps

    Adhesives

    Future

    References




    Wound Assessment

    Wound management requires information about:
        - Time and mechanism of injury
        - Condition (diseases or disorders)
        - Practice (Smoking or drugs)
        - Medications (corticosteroids, chemotherapeutic agents)
        - Nutritional status
        - Arterial or venous insufficiency in wounded area

    Wound inspection necessary to check for:
        - Active hemorrhage
        - Viability of wounded tissue
        - Presence of foreign bodies
        - Potential damage to structures in vicinity of wound

Back to top



   
Timing and Methods

    The main goals of wound treatment are a) Close the wound and b) Establish wound healing
    Closure timing is important in order to meet these main goals. Closure timings are:

        1. Primary Closure - Close wound at time of presentation
        2. Secondary Closure - Allow would to heal by itself
        3. Tertiary Closure - Close wound after a period of secondary healing

    Deciding the type of closure depends on whether the wound will satisfactorily heal on its own and whether hemorrhage, dead tissue and foreign bodies, and bacterial contamination can be adequately dealt with

        Wounds without hemorrhage, necrotic tissue, foreign bodies, or contamination
          Primary closure works well in this situation; no extensive wound care is needed and the wound will reach a healed state quickly

        Wounds with hemorrhage
          Hemorrhage can be controlled without difficulty in most wounds by using pressure, cauterization, or ligation. Wound cannot be closed if it is still bleeding because the hematomas act as a barrier to the healing. Hematomas must first be drained before closure can occur. Small hematomas may allow for secondary closure, whereas larger hematomas usually require primary closure

        Wounds with foreign bodies and necrotic tissue
          Foreign bodies and necrotic tissue must first be removed before closure. Most foreign bodies and necrotic tissue can be removed without difficulty either manually or with high-pressure saline irrigation. For more firmly embedded foreign bodies, surgical excision can be used for removal. For foreign material that was injected, such as paint or grease injected under pressure, radiographs can help determine the spread of material in the target area. Radiopaque materials, such as metals or leaded glass, can also be detected with a radiograph. For other materials that cannot be easily visualized, techniques to use include xeroradiography, magnified radiographs and CT scans.

         Side Note: For burn wounds, it extremely difficult to assess tissue damage because the injury may become worse in the few days after the burn. This is the reason why closure of burn wounds is often delayed

        Wounds with bacterial contamination
        A wound with greater than 10organisms/gram tissue is considered infected. A visual inspection is not adequate to assess bacterial counts so cultures need to be performed. The rapid slide technique is effective in that it provides bacteria counts within an hour. Age of the wound is important in that it correlates with bacteria counts. The first 6-8 hours after a wound is called the "golden period" because clinical studies show that there are less than 10organisms/gram tissue within that time and so the wound can be closed safely. Other important factors to consider are the location (areas with greater blood supply tend to resist infection) and immune status (younger people less likely to become infected).
         Topical creams can reduce the number of bacteria in a wound. A commonly used agent is Silvadene (made from silver sulfadiazine). It has a broad antibacterial spectrum and does not adversely affect metabolism like other agents (mafenide, silver nitrate). Silver sulfadiazine is also thought to increase epithelialization rate, thus leading to faster wound healing.

Once the wound is ready to be closed, the appropriate type of closure method must be chosen. The major methods of wound closure are:
            1. Direct approximation (Suture/Staple)
            2. Autograft
            3. Flap

Back to top               

   

    Pre-closure Steps

        Anesthesia   
         The first step to take before wound closure is proper anesthesia. The most commonly used anesthetic is lidocaine (0.5% or 1.0%) because of its fast-acting capability, rare instances of allergic reactions, and the 1-2 hours of local anesthesia it provides which is usually enough time for most wound closures. Often combined with lidocaine is epinephrine, which makes the anesthetic effective for a longer time and helps with hemostasis

        Irrigation
         Irrigation with a high-pressure spray is necessary to reduce the number of bacteria that may be present. Commonly used irrigants include 0.9% saline solution and Pluronic F-68, which has surfactant properties that improve wound cleaning. Antibiotics can be added in order to remove more bacteria if necessary

        Skin preparation
         The surrounding tissue should be prepared with an antibacterial solution, a common one being povidone-iodine. Foreign matter and necrotic tissue should be removed to reduce chances of infection. If conditions allow, wound edges should be made smooth and level using incisions
 
                Side Note: Some solutions should not be placed on wounds. These include:
                            - Povidone-iodine (will damage tissue)
                            - Chlorhexidine (impedes wound healing)
                            - Alcohol (toxic to tissues)
                            - Sodium hypochlorite (toxic to fibroblasts, slows epithelial growth)
                            - Acetic acid (toxic to fibroblasts, slows epithelial growth)
                            - Hydrogen peroxide (histologic damage to tissue)
                            - Standard hand soap (can induce histologic damage)

        *Ideal wound closure*
                - Support wound until it reaches near-full strength
                - No inflammation
                - No ischemia
                - No penetration of epidermis (potential for additional scarring)
                - No interference with healing process

       For wounds, regaining strength takes a long time. Collagen fibers are usually growing by the third day of injury but the skin wound has no tensile strength. Blood vessels cross the wound by 8 days, as well as epithelial cells and fibrinous coagulum. The skin gains strength from 8-21 days and continues to gain for 4 months. It is sometimes difficult to make the balance between maintaining wound strength and cosmetic appearance. Currently no wound closure techniques accomplish all the requirements for ideal wound closure. The requirements always have to be balanced depending on the situation

Back to top



   
Sutures

 Sutures are commonly used when the wound is small and clean enough that the wound edges can be brought together without deformation. Suture material should be chosen based on:
        - Interaction of material with wound and surrounding tissue
        - Configuration of tissue
        - Biomechanical properties of wound

before and after
        Pre- and post-suturing


Two general classes of sutures are absorbable (rapidly degrade and lose tensile strength within 60 days) and nonabsorbable (maintain strength for more than 60 days). The type must be chosen depending on the type of wound

        Nonabsorbable sutures
              Silk - Sterile, non-mutagenic made of natural proteinaceous fibers called fibroin
              Metallic - Derived from stainless steel

Polyamides - Nylon, high tensile strength and low reactivity but relatively large degradation rate in vivo (12.5% per year). Pliable and easy to handle, favored for interrupted percutaneous sutures
Polyesters - Dacron, last indefinitely in tissue, coated with lubricant to reduce large coefficient of friction
 Polypropylene - Very inert in tissue, retain tensile strength for long time, low drag coefficient so good for continuous techniques. Used in plastic, cardiovascular, general, and orthopedic surgery
 Polybutester -  Unique elongation changes compared to other sutures; low forces result in longer elongation and high elasticity allows suture to adapt to changing tensions and removing risk of hypertrophic scars. Coated with absorbable pollymer to reduce drag forces in musculoaponeurotic, colonic, and vascular tissue

    Non-absorbing suture
                                                    Non-absorbing suture
   

        Absorbable sutures
     Made from collagen or synthetic polymers treated with aldehyde (to resist enzymatic degradation). Disadvantages of natural fiber sutures include fraying during knotting and more variability in tensile strength.
       POLYSORB - Synthesis of copolymers of glycolide (provides tensile strength) and lactide (controls rate of hydrolysis for prolonged strength)
       CAPROSYN - Latest development in monofilament absorbable sutures, retains strength for longer than other absorbable sutures, greater breaking strength, less rate of infection, and lower drag forces

    Types of suture techniques are dermal and percutaneous, and each can be continuous or interrupted

             Continuous - More rapidly done, accomodates to edema

Interrupted - Must make knot for each loop (longer surgery time), constricts tissue more so cannot accomodate for edema, but is more precise for approximating wounds
             Percutaneous - Easier to operate upon, but leaves scars
             Dermal - More difficult to suture, but stronger, no visible scars, and does not need removal

Suture knot
            Suture knot

Back to top


   
Staples

    Skin stapling has been shown to be an effective method to close wounds. Stapes have several advantages over sutures, including much greater resistance to infection, greater approximation of wound edges, decreased wound closure time, 6-8 times faster to approximate wound edges, and more cost effective. The main disadvantage is the strength starting three weeks after closure, where the sutures were shown to be significantly stronger. Additionally, approximation is not as precise as with sutures

Staples in surgery

    Skin staples are made of metal and are applied using a skin stapler. There are many brands of skin stapler, each with their own advantages and disadvantages. In general, most brands are effective and can be used in most applications requiring stapling.

    APPOSE Skin Stapler
                                                APPOSE Skin Stapler


                                                        MULTIFIRE Skin Stapler
                                                             MULTIFIRE Skin Stapler

Back to top


    Grafts and Flaps

    When a wound is severe enough that the edges cannot be approximated without excessive tension or deformation of skin and surrounding tissue, other methods are needed. Skin grafts and flaps use tissue from another location of the body to replace the lost tissue at the wound site.




    Grafts must be protected from infection, bleeding, and shearing until it has reached maturity. Once it has matured, it will regain perspiration and sensiility characteristics of the recipient site rather than the donor site.

    Skin grafts cannot heal over areas >1.0-1.5 cm2 of denuded bone, nerve, or tendon because those areas have most likely become avascular and a skin graft will not revascularize. For those situations, a flap can be used because they do not require complete revascularization since they use the vasculature from their original site. Flaps retain color, texture, hair, and other activity. Sensibility and perspiration are eventually regained.


        Illustration of flap method

    Additionally, use of skin substitutes has also been attempted. Alloderm and Integra contain dermal elements of skin, while Apligraf contains other components as well, including epithelium. Improvements are still necessary for skin substitutes, however.

Back to top



   
Adhesives

    Tissue adhesives have primarily been used in repair of traumatic lacerations in the Emergency Department. Adhesives have an advantage over sutures in that they rapidly unite wound edges, there is no need to remove them like for sutures, and they are less painful for application. Three commonly used adhesives are Histoacryl, Dermabond, and Indermil. They have been shown to be highly effective in their use. These adhesives can also be more cost effective for certain applications, such as pediatric facial lacerations. A downside is that tissue can adversely react to the compounds

                           
 Cyanoacrylate Adhesive                            Adhesives used in glaucona drainage

Back to top



    Future

    Currently, methods to close severe wounds are generally very effective when applied to the proper situations. Because different methods exist (suture, staple, grafts and flaps, and adhesives), different types of wounds can be handled and treated. There are still many ways to improve wound repair, however. One improvement would be to decrease the time needed for suture insertion and tying. If a device were to be constructed that could be set to automatically insert the sutures and knot them, it would save a great deal of time and effort for the surgeons.
     Each closure method itself can be improved, but an ideal improvement to wound treatment in general could include one standard type of treatment for all wounds. This seems very difficult because the severity and types of wounds is so varied, but a standard treatment would make things much easier for surgeons. No time would be lost deciding what closure method is best, and no training would be needed for several different types of closure.
    Another improvement to wound healing could involve ways to make tissue repair faster. Faster healing would allow the closure device to be removed sooner and thus would improve the cosmetic aspect of wound closure.
Ways to accomplish this could include growth factors and hormones to instigate growth. The field of tissue engineering deals with this and could be applied to create more effective wound closure and repair methods. 
    In conclusion, methods of wound closure are currently effective but can still be improved, modified, and combined with different techniques to create superior techniques to save time, increase cost efficiency, increase comfort of patients and decrease effort for surgeons

Back to top



References

Lawrence, Thomas W; Bevin, Griswold A; Sheldon, George F. "Acute wound care: approach to acute wound management." ACS Surgery Online, 2002

Lin, Kant Y; Long, William B III. "Revolutionary advances in skin stapling and tissue adhesives." Dannemiller Memorial Educational Foundation, 2005

Lin, Kant Y; Long, William B III. "Scientific basis for the selection of surgical needles and sutures." Dannemiller Memorial Educational Foundation, 2005

Lin, Kant Y; Long, William B III. "Scientific basis for the selection of sutural skin closure." Dannemiller Memorial Educational Foundation, 2005

Schmidt, Ben. "Advances in medical textiles: novel suture technologies." Jour TATM, 2004

Back to top



This website was created by Ashish Jani for BME 240, taught by Professors Brian Wong and Ranjan Gupta. This project is under the name of the University of California, Irvine and was completed June 2007